Review: Dime Novel Mormons

Ardis Parshall and Michael (Mike) Austin give us Dime Novel Mormonsa new delight in The Mormon Image in Literature series, published by Greg Kofford Books.

I’ve been head down in other things, but when I’ve come up for air, it’s been refreshing to contemplate the forgotten art of “books” that could be purchased for mere pennies. “Dime novels,” as they were called even when even less expensive, were sweeping adventures. They were something like comic books without pictures, making reading accessible to everyone. They were the Instagram of their day.

Not all dime novels featured Mormons. In fact, Ardis and Mike indicate the number of dime novels that included Mormons as characters probably made up less than 0.1% of all dime novels published. However these dime novels presented Mormonism to those who had no other concept of Mormons and their beliefs and practices.

The tropes we see in the dime novels included in this volume were repeated in other, more prestigious, forms of entertainment.

  • Arthur Conan Doyle’s first Sherlock Holmes story, A Study in Scarlet, features malevolent Mormons abducting a fair maiden who then dies of despair.Doyle was a young physician at the time, struggling to make ends meet. When initially challenged regarding his depiction of Mormons, he reportedly responded, “all I said about the Danite Band and the murders is historical so I cannot withdraw that, though it is likely that in a work of fiction it is stated more luridly than in a work of history. It’s best to let the matter rest.”
  • At the 2016 MHA Conference, Ardis discussed the investigation Winston Churchill opened into whether Mormons were indeed entrapping British maidens to emigrate to America and be coerced to submit to the evils of Mormonism. The official investigation found no such coersion was occurring.
  • A savvy consumer will see fragments of the dime novel depictions of Mormons slathered throughout modern media, particularly TV crime procedurals when they encounter “cults.”

The four dime novels in this collection are overtly anti-Mormon, but are valuable precisely because they either informed later depictions or represent the evolution of how Mormons were depicted in response to significant events.

Eagle Plume, the White Avenger. A Tale of the Mormon Trail (1870)

Eagle Plume was not the first dime novel to feature Mormons, but this is the volume that created the mythos of the Danites, the allegedly murderous pack of villains that have populated unknown numbers of cheap books and nightmares ever since. As Ardis and Mike state in their introduction, “Nearly all of the anti-Mormon stereotypes of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries can be traced genealogically back to Eagle Plume, the White Avenger.”

In real life, the Danites were a bunch of overly-anxious men circa 1837-1838 who thought it might be useful to kill disaffected Mormons. The Danites believed these disaffected Mormons were responsible for the killings, rapes, and destruction committed by non-Mormons in Missouri. But Joseph Smith commanded these few to repent or in other words, turn the other cheek. There have been no Danites since 1838.

The Doomed Dozen; or, Dolores, the Danite’s Daughter (1881)

This alliteratively-titled volume features Buffalo Bill Cody as the hero, with such subtlely-named characters as “Satan’s Pet.” The primary villain is Danite leader, John Leigh, obviously based on John D. Lee. In real history, Lee was convicted of being responsible for the Mountain Meadows Massacre and was subsequently executed in 1877. The Doomed Dozen brings together all the standard anti-Mormon stereotypes in one place, with Buffalo Bill thrown in to save the day.

Frank Merriwell Among the Mormons; or, The Lost Tribes of Israel (1897)

The character Frank Merriwell was expressly created as a role model for boys: clean living, athletic, and brave. Frank Merriwell would survive the end of dime novels and go on to save the day in radio dramas, comic books, and motion pictures.

The villains in Frank Merriwell Among the Mormons are not mainstream Mormons, but a radical sect of Mormons living in the mountains, who have rejected the Manifesto. As Mike mentions in the Q&A, “Frank Merriwell points out that the rising generation of Mormons are good citizens who are opposed to polygamy. In 1897, in a dime novel, this amounts to something like high praise.”

The Bradys Among the Mormons; or, Secret Work in Salt Lake City (1903)

By 1903 the wilderness had been tamed, and dime novels turned from horse-riding heroics to detectives. The Bradys Among the Mormons was written after the election of Reed Smoot, a Mormon Apostle, to represent Utah in the US Senate. As sometimes happens after elections, opponents demanded an investigation. The Smoot Hearings went on for four years, filling the newspapers of the day with “every peculiarity of Mormonism, especially its polygamous family structure, ritual worship practices, “secret oaths,” open canon, economic communalism, and theocratic politics.”

The aspiring Mormon politician in The Bradys Among the Mormons is Mr. Joseph Smith Podmore, a Mormon who is courting the daughter of a sitting US Senator and planning to run for the Senate himself. The Bradys are called in to investigate, and soon uncover a secret world of Danites, tunnels, murder, and polygamy.

Ardis and Mike presented a brief Q&A on Dime Novel Mormons, which I highly recommend. Dime Novel Mormons is available for pre-order and will be formally published on March 21.

As I reflect on my past, I remember a time when I told a work colleague that I was getting married. With a look of dread, the man asked, “Is your fiancé Mormon?” When I said he was, my colleague replied with sorrow and may have wept, saying “You will never be saved now.” Reading these dime novels gives me perspective on why various people I have know had such strange ideas about Mormons and why they felt it was acceptable to be so impolite. And if you can suspend a feeling of deep outrage at the gross factual distortions contained in these books, you will likely have a great time reading the tales.



This entry was posted in General by Meg Stout. Bookmark the permalink.

About Meg Stout

Meg Stout has been an active member of the Church of Jesus Christ (of Latter-day Saints) for decades. She lives in the DC area with her husband, Bryan, and several daughters. She is an engineer by vocation and a writer by avocation. Meg is the author of Reluctant Polygamist, laying out the possibility that Joseph taught the acceptability of plural marriage but that Emma was right to assert she had been Joseph's only true wife.

2 thoughts on “Review: Dime Novel Mormons

  1. I was complaining to a rep of Kofford Books about the size of the font, and he told me it was still about 4 pts. larger than the original. I would have had to use a magnifying glass to read the original. Kudos to Michael and Ardis.

    I guess they could sell the books for a dime because they conserved on paper.

Comments are closed.