Knit Hearts of the Past

Nauvoo has long captivated me. But it wasn’t until 2015 that I decided I wanted to move there someday.

As of this week I am the delighted owner of a brick home on Mulholland Street, within easy walking distance of the Nauvoo temple and all the businesses in town.

The home has curb appeal and the “built in 1850” note suggested historical significance. It’s been fun tracing the history of the original families to build the home as it now is. And in what was a family living in a mostly Catholic Nauvoo, I found an unexpected tie to Mormonism.

When visiting the house this past fall, I asked what the realtor might know of the former inhabitants. She didn’t know anything.

But in an upstairs room I noticed a framed montage.

Getting on the internet, I found additional documentation regarding both the home and the adjacent shop. The original builder was one John Tanner, a Swiss-born man who arrived in Nauvoo as the Mormons were preparing to flee Nauvoo. 1

Members of the Tanner family lived in the home until 1963. Though Elizabeth Tanner had been a close friend of Joseph Smith’s widow, Emma Smith Bidamon, a quick glance at Family Search indicated the Tanners had never been Mormons.

The home eventually went to the Tanner’s only surviving daughter, Sophia, who had married Tanner’s young business partner, Henry Harsch. Sophia would live in the home until 1963, passing away just before her 100th birthday.

The Relief Society Gatherings of Nauvoo

As I researched Sophia Harsch, I was surprised to find the following letter in the Relief Society Magazine:

I am very happy and thankful that Mrs. Elizabeth Hogan is sending The Relief Society Magazine to me. I surely appreciate her kindness. I love to attend Relief Society meetings. We are snowbound — had no meeting tonight (March 9, 1960). I live in Nauvoo, Illinois. My dear mother was a friend of Emma Smith, wife of the Prophet Joseph Smith. I am ninety-six years old and have spent many pleasant hours reading the Magazine. The story “A Is for Apron” (August, September, and October 1959, by Ilene H. Kingsbury) touched my heart. Many thanks for the good Magazine.

— Sophia Harsch, Nauvoo, Illinois

Had Sophia been Mormon? A return to Family Search showed that Sophia hadn’t been baptized during her lifetime, though proxy ordinances were performed for Sophia and her husband shortly after her passing.

Next I turned to the mysterious “Mrs. Hogan.” Was she someone in Salt Lake? Perhaps she was a missionary serving in the Nauvoo area.

But the only likely Elizabeth Hogan appears to have been Mary Elizabeth Doolittle Hogan. Mrs. Hogan lived in Niota, Illinois, less than 10 miles from Nauvoo and just across the Mississippi from Fort Madison, Iowa. Elizabeth Hogan’s husband had grown up in Nauvoo with Sophia. From all evidence, Elizabeth Hogan was a staunch Catholic lady, mother to six children.

Yet Elizabeth Hogan had subscribed to the Relief Society Magazine and was sending a copy to her long-time friend and fellow widow, Sophia. A group of women in the Nauvoo area would meet together on Wednesday nights, considering these meetings to be part of the Relief Society tradition that had begun in Nauvoo on Thursday, March 17, 1842. It seems possible that this Nauvoo Relief Society tradition had continued after Brigham Young left Nauvoo, as Emma gathered with new friends who came to Nauvoo after 1846.

But on March 9, 1960, a heavy snow prevented the ladies in the Nauvoo area from meeting. So Sophia Harsch took the time she usually would have spent with her Nauvoo Relief Society group to write a note of thanks to the Utah folks who published a Relief Society Magazine.

In my own life I get to participate with a small group of Relief Society sisters who meet for book group, scripture study, and knitting, groups that continued from an alternate approach to what had been “Homemaking Meetings” back in the day. These groups also include neighbors and friends who aren’t formally members of the Church or Relief Society. But they are our friends and part of our gatherings. We gather and talk, sometimes literally knitting, other times talking about our loved ones and triumphs, as well as loss of loved ones and trials. And through it all our lives become knit together.

In my own community of friends, then, I see a pattern for Nauvoo’s 1960 “Relief Society,” a gathering of women as friends, inspired by Emma Smith’s Relief Society but without any necessary tie to the LDS Church.

On the off-chance that you are interested in the additional information I learned, click to read more.

1845 – Wagon Maker and Fruit Farmer

Swiss-born John Tanner came to Nauvoo in the last year of Mormon settlement to help build wagons. According to Tanner’s daughter, John Tanner set out 2 1/2 acres of Norton grapes in 1847, making him one of the first of those who would make Nauvoo famous for its grapes and wines.

1848-1851 – Icarians and the Adelsverein

In 1848 John Tanner married Elizabeth Stauder, a young German woman who had been born in Neustadt on the Rhine.

The 1840s were a time of civil unrest in Europe. Two groups who fled Europe in the 1840s for a better life in America would eventually gather to Nauvoo. Both of these groups had lived in Texas in locations where Lyman Wight’s Mormon followers had lived.

Frenchman Étienne Cabet promoted the idea of a non-religious communitarian ideal and at one time claimed 50,000 dedicated to his views. They called themselves Icarians after the fictional land of Icaria featured in Cabet’s novelistic utopian treatise. A small advance group of Icarians attempted settle in Texas, but soon faced death as they tried to homestead bizarrely divided undeveloped plots. The Icarian plots near the Red River were in a county adjacent to where Lyman Wight had initially settled in Texas.

Germans also came to Texas, fleeing the troubles of Europe. The Adelsverein was a German organization founded in Biebrich on the Rhine, focused on establishing a New Germany in Texas through organized mass emigration. The hope for a large German settlement in North America was soon confronted by the reality of inadequate funds, miserable living conditions, and fatal illnesses. In the summer of 1847 an attempted coup d’état divided the community. While a significant percentage of the hundreds of Adelsverein emigrants remained in Texas, many families either returned to Germany or moved elsewhere.

The prospect of Nauvoo, a deserted town on a major waterway, appealed to both Icarians and the discontented Adelsverein. Because the partial Adelsverein diaspora from Texas was more diverse than the Icarian departure from Texas, it has not been featured in the stories told about Nauvoo. Yet it seems likely Elizabeth Stauder and other Germans who gathered to Nauvoo in the late 1840s were among the Adelsverein who left Texas after the disastrous summer of 1847.

1850/2 – Building on Temple Remains

By 1849 the Tanners welcomed their first child. Whatever structure had served as home before was no longer adequate. So John constructed a brick home, built on a foundation of the large white stones that remained after the elements had destroyed the Nauvoo temple. The windows for both the brick home and Tanner’s adjacent workshop were styled after the windows in the Red Brick Store, with large white window sills and lintels carved from the same stone that had been used for the Nauvoo temple.

At some point the Tanners expanded their home by adding a clapboard addition facing the street. This may have been done very soon after initial construction, as the cellar walls that supported the clapboard addition feature large temple stones. It is possible and even likely the cellar was used to store wine produced from the grapes John Tanner had introduced to Nauvoo.

The Tanners welcomed at least six children into their family. 2 Four of their children died prematurely. It was likely in the crucible of these losses that Elizabeth became close friends with Emma Smith Bidamon, widow of Joseph Smith.

1900s –  A World in Flux

In 1896 the Tanner’s only surviving daughter, Sophia, married John Tanner’s young partner, Henry Harsch. The Tanner and Harsch couples lived in the brick and clapboard home Tanner had built, a home with no electricity or indoor plumbing. The men would spend their days in the adjacent shop making wagons and working on cultivating grapes. The women tended to more domestic tasks, such as woolen yarn production. But the time of shared co-housing ended when Elizabeth and John passed away in 1906 and 1908.

By 1910 the carding and spinning that was a primary home industry for American women in the 1800s had been overtaken by mechanical devices. Wagons were being replaced by automobiles. Electricity and indoor plumbing transformed the nature of domestic life. And new home construction materials had an answer to the fear of fire that had been stoked by the Great Chicago Fire of 1871 and the San Francisco Fire of 1906.

1910 – Sears Modern Home Renovation

Henry and Sophia Harsch decided to remodel their home, transforming it from the “primitive” brick and clapboard structure into a modern home with indoor plumbing and electricity. They were likely inspired by the Hamilton, the more elaborate of two Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired Prairie Box or Foursquare designs in the 1908 Sears catalog. Parts and labor for Sears Modern Homes (1908-1940) cost a fraction of the materials and labor required previously. In addition to facilitating modern plumbing and electricity, the Sears homes featured fire-retardant features like dry wall and asphalt shingles. The Sears Modern Home program encouraged homeowners to adapt the designs as needed. All materials and fittings were then pre-cut and shipped to the buyer in a boxcar. The Harsch family chose to make their renovation brick rather than clapboard and retained the distinctive window design that had been based on the Red Brick Store.

It’s possible Henry Harsch intended his Mulholland Street residence to be a showcase to inspire others, transforming his business from that of wagon maker to general contractor. By 1920 the census lists Henry as proprietor of a repair shop, rather than as the fruit farmer or wagon maker he’d been listed as previously. When Henry Harsch upgraded his home in 1910, it was one of the finest homes in town, surpassed only by the home belonging to the town’s banker. 3

Henry Harsch and Sophia had no children. and Henry would only get to live in their new “modern” home until 1925, when he passed away at the relatively young age of 62. Sophia would live in the home alone for nearly forty years following her husband’s death.

Addendum: Frank Lloyd Wright Proto-Prairie Four Square, circa 1900


Frank Lloyd Wright was interested not only in pushing the boundaries of home design, but in making homes that would improve life. This Frank Lloyd Wright home built in Chicago in 1900 incorporates the “fireproof” brick and asphalt that we see copied in the Tanner-Harsch home on Mulholland.

It’s not hard to imagine where Henry Harsch derived the inspiration for his 1910 remodel. Chicago architects, such as Frank Lloyd Wright, were inventing a new and uniquely American style of architecture that was the epitome of modernity at the time.

Frank Lloyd Wright wrote three illustrated articles about his post-1900 home concepts that were published in Ladies Home Journal. These were “A Home in a Prairie Town” (Feb 1901, see illustration below), “A Small House with ‘Lots of Room in It’” (Jul 1901) and “A Fireproof House for $5000” (Apr 1907).

The lofty concepts of the Frank Lloyd Wright homes became practical possibilities in the 1908 Sears catalog home designs.

Notes:

  1. On the 1900 census John reported that he’d immigrated in 1846. Sophia wrote that her father arrived in Nauvoo in November 1846, but that is too late to support his reported recollection that he built many wagon wheels for the departing Saints and saw a town of thousands dwindle to a small fraction of that number. It is more likely John Tanner arrived in Nauvoo in November 1845.
  2. From the recorded dates for children born, it appears Elizabeth suffered either two miscarriages or had two children pass away shortly after birth.
  3. Assessment based on 1940 census information, which gave home values for each household. The Harsch home was valued at $4000, as were several other residences. The banker’s home was valued at $4500. The Hart residence and the home of an aeronautical engineer, both built after 1910, were valued at $5000.
This entry was posted in General by Meg Stout. Bookmark the permalink.

About Meg Stout

Meg Stout has been an active member of the LDS church for decades. She lives in the DC area with her husband, Bryan, and several daughters. She is an engineer by vocation and a writer by avocation. Meg is the author of Reluctant Polygamist, laying out the possibility that Joseph taught the acceptability of plural marriage but may have privately defied the commandment for love of his wife, Emma.

13 thoughts on “Knit Hearts of the Past

  1. Yes – it was built right after the tornado finished off the temple as a useable structure – a process that had started with a fire in 1848.

  2. Great congratulations Meg! Gorgeous living station! I think that house was actually built earlier though, and the Nauvoo Expositor was published out of there.

    Kidding. 🙂

  3. I really liked Nauvoo when we visited a few summers back. Nice town filled with history.

  4. Meg,
    I don’t know if you already know this, but membership in the Relief Society went beyond LDS women even in Utah. I was raised in a small Utah mining town, which was only about 50% LDS (at most) during the period of 1890-1940. But my grandmother estimated that “the majority” of non-LDS women were members of the RS. Back in those days, one simply paid the membership dues (RS magazine subscription) and you were in.

    Grandma lived to age 94, but I still remember recounting how proud women were to be members.

  5. I actually wouldn’t mind if it turned out that property had previously been the side of the Expositor, as my ancestor Austin Cowles was involved with the Expositor.

    It’s not impossible because that property is across the street from Foster’s Hotel, and Foster had been one of those contributing to the Expositor.

  6. Hey Old Man,

    Thank you for that! I haven’t personally been aware that the membership of Relief Society extend so far outside of “LDS “members.

    My female ancestors of always been members of the church, so research into my own family history hadn’t highlighted the way that Relief Society embraced all women in the community. And from what I had read in the other histories of the Relief Society, I didn’t recall coming across mention of how Relief Society extended into the broader community.

  7. Looking it up, the Expositor was located on the second story of the brick building on Mulholland St in the block east of the temple, which I believe refers to Foster’s hotel. The original brick structure has since burned down. The State Bank of Nauvoo now occupies that space. http://www.lds-mormon.com/06.shtml

  8. Thank you for the post, Meg. I very much enjoyed it, and the different stories told. Our ward also has a book group which meets once a month, though I don’t attend. (Different choices of books.) I’ve taught knitting to YW, but our adult women aren’t really interested. And a small group of RS sisters who wanted to learn to quilt, petered out after less than a year.
    The idea of women meeting routinely just for the pleasure sounds quite enjoyable to me. Some wards and some years are more agreeable to this than others. I hope you enjoy your beautiful and well lived home for many years to come.

  9. Meg, so you guys retired and moved? Or is this a vacation/investment home for the time being?

    And are we to read anything into “_I_ am the delighted owner…” with no mention of Mr. Stout?

  10. LOL,

    I plan to retire in March 2025. And my beloved husband is happy to accept that I’ve decided that we will retire to a place within walking distance (or handicapped scooter ride distance) of a temple, even if it will eventually take him away from friends (many) and activities (e.g., Mormon Choir) that he enjoys. My autistic daughter is delighted about the prospect of living in a small town where she is walking distance to everything. This eventual move, while it delights me, is primarily inspired by providing my daughter a living situation that will allow her to have a delightful life in the decades to come.

    When I first determined that we were willing to move to Nauvoo upon retirement, I started checking out the market. I learned that the local community doesn’t want the entire town bought up as investment properties to be rented out to missionaries and summer tourists, so only properties on Mulholland Street are allowed to be rented out on a night by night basis (unless there is some special grandfathering or the home is so distant from town center that no one cares).

    While my regular trolling on Zillow wasn’t restricted to Mulholland, I was unusually interested when I saw this house available for purchase. After two years trolling, I was relatively certain I wouldn’t be able to find something that was both so appropriate for my daughter’s future home *and* fit to be an investment property until 2025.

    For what it’s worth, a fellow who had been snapping up properties in Nauvoo over the past decades has recently decided to divest himself of these. So the Nauvoo market is currently flooded with inexpensive homes. Which I suppose means I could have snapped up a simple cottage on a postage stamp for half what I paid for this house. But there is no guarantee such an inexpensive cottage would be available next decade (Nauvoo is growing significantly faster than other small towns in the vicinity) and without the potential as an investment property, I wouldn’t be able to swing purchasing the home now.

    Of interest, properties that can accommodate large groups and that can be rented out on a nightly basis can command on the order of $500 a night during Nauvoo’s tourist season (lasting roughly 60 days). And it appears that all such properties that are currently available are already booked a year in advance. The home I have purchased has an extra building that could be modified to bump the property into that “large group” category. On the other hand, Nauvoo is lacking in public spaces for general events (e.g., art shows, lectures) that aren’t directly affiliated with one of the religious constituencies in town. So perhaps I work with the community on the modest transformation that would allow the space to be an event center.

    At any rate, I look forward to a future when I or mine are old and less mobile, where we can still have easy access to temple, food, custard, fitness center, and chapel, though not all would order the necessities in that order. The kindness of others is wonderful, but independence is also wonderful.

Comments are closed.