True and counterfeit plans through the eternities

Those of us who chose in the pre-mortal world to come to the Earth spotted two fatal flaws in Satan’s plan to save us all.

Satan’s plan did not allow for free will and had Satan at the center. Said Satan:

“Behold, here am I, send me, I will be thy son, and I will redeem all mankind, that one soul shall not be lost, and surely I will do it; wherefore give me thine honor.” (Moses 4:1).

In contrast, Jehovah, the true Savior, said:

“Father, thy will be done, and the glory be thine forever.” (Moses 4:2).

Jehovah’s statement, which supported Heavenly Father’s plan, allowed for free choice. This meant that some people will ultimately choose not to be saved, but the Lord, in his wisdom, realizes that you cannot force people to be good. In addition, Jehovah’s plan puts the Lord at the center.

Jehovah’s plan looks like this:

plan of salvation

Note that Jehovah’s plan relies on individuals freely deciding to take on the name of the Lord and join the House of Israel. The Lord is at the center. Some people will decide not to accept this plan. Those who do accept it will “be one” with the Lord and will have eternal increase, meaning they will progress and become more and more like God.

Satan’s plan is a counterfeit of this plan. It looks like this:

satan's plan

Note that Satan’s plan involves him forcing his will on others. There is no free choice. While in theory “one soul shall not be lost,” the reality is that the coercion involved puts Satan at the center of the plan, rather than the Lord. And of course Satan wants all the glory for himself.

(The first step of Satan’s plan may have been to allow people to be saved in their sins, meaning that they can do whatever they want and still be “saved.” The end game, however, was for Satan to step in and institute his own system based on controlling people’s actions.)

As humanity has lived on the Earth, it has sought models for setting up societies that allow people to prosper and be at peace. We see glimpses of models that work in 4 Nephi and in the early New Testament period. In effect, people are striving to create Zion, the ancient city of Enoch, which “the Lord called…Zion, because they were of one heart and one mind, and dwelt in righteousness, and there was no poor among them.” (Moses 7:18).

We know through modern-day revelation that creating Zion involves voluntarily consecrating yourself to the Lord through his Church. But note that the model does not include all people on the Earth. Some people will choose, for whatever reason, not to join the Zion society. Jesus recognized that some people would become lost sheep. We should seek them out and bring them back to the fold, but some of them will choose not to join Zion.

To create a Zion society, people need to be One in purpose and they need to place the Lord at the center. A Zion society looks like this:

a just society

The American experience is about creating a “city on a hill” that is meant, at is heart, to create something approaching a Zion society. There has always been a strain in American history of utopianism. One of the most unique features of the American experience from the early 1600s until 1789 was the combination of personal freedom and personal responsibility to better society. This resulted in the Constitution, which enshrines the rights to “life, liberty and property” that are the center of a Zion society. This society obviously was not perfect (slavery was not abolished for many decades), but the desire for a just and perfect society comes through in the writings of all of the Founding Fathers. The goal, in the end, was a society where people governed themselves and voluntarily chose the right.

The Constitution, through its system of checks and balances, intended most of all to prevent the creation of a tyrannical government. Unfortunately, the history of humanity is that the vast majority of societies end up with tyrannical domination. All tyrants are aware that the people want peace, want justice and want prosperity. The people also want the poor to receive help, but unfortunately many people don’t want to do that often dirty work themselves. So tyrants will promise, peace, will promise justice, will promise prosperity and will promise to “help the poor.” What they will deliver is always the exact opposite.

A tyrannical society looks like this:

tyrannical society

Notice that just as Satan is the center of his counterfeit plan of salvation, the tyrant becomes the center of his false Zion society.

Modern-day prophets have repeatedly warned us about the ideologies that will create counterfeit versions of Zion.

Heber J. Grant:

“We again warn our people in America of the constantly increasing threat against our inspired Constitution and our free institutions set up under it. The same political tenets and philosophies that have brought war and terror in other parts of the world are at work amongst us in America…

“… Communism and all other similar isms bear no relationship whatever to the United Order. They are merely the clumsy counterfeits which Satan always devises of the gospel plan… Latter-day Saints cannot be true to their faith and lend aid, encouragement, or sympathy to any of these false philosophies. They will prove snares to their feet.”

Joseph Smith in the 1840s was exposed to Socialism, and said the following:

“I attended a second lecture on Socialism, by Mr. Finch; and after he got through, I made a few remarks… I said I did not believe the doctrine.” (History of the Church 6:33)

Just two years ago, Elder Uchtdorf pointed out that the world’s way of helping the poor is not the Lord’s way:

There are many good people and organizations in the world that are trying to meet the pressing needs of the poor and needy everywhere. We are grateful for this, but the Lord’s way of caring for the needy is different from the world’s way. The Lord has said, “It must needs be done in mine own way.” He is not only interested in our immediate needs; He is also concerned about our eternal progression. For this reason, the Lord’s way has always included self-reliance and service to our neighbor in addition to caring for the poor.

A true Zion society will involve people voluntarily choosing to be one. This will naturally grow into seeing all people as our brothers and sisters. We will rejoice in helping people who need assistance. There will be no coercion.

The false model always ends up with some tyrant — or group of tyrants — forcing people to do things they do not want to do. These tyrants will always tell people that they must bring “equality” or “social justice,” but it is always their version of equality and social justice imposed by force on society. Inevitably, these tyrants benefit financially from the unjust society they create. This is the exact opposite of Zion.

The crucial building-block of a Zion society — and in fact the Lord’s creation of the House of Israel — is a family headed by a mother and a father. The Proclamation to the World on the family says:

WE, THE FIRST PRESIDENCY and the Council of the Twelve Apostles of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, solemnly proclaim that marriage between a man and a woman is ordained of God and that the family is central to the Creator’s plan for the eternal destiny of His children.

The Lord is at the center of this relationship, which looks like this:

true marriage graffic

The world has seen many counterfeit models of this relationship over time. Marriage has been used for financial reasons, or to create dynasties that have nothing to do with a lasting, loving relationship. People have casually entered into marriage, only to ignore vows taken just a few days later. And now we are seeing same-sex attraction and bonding being called “marriage.”

Here is a counterfeit version of marriage:

temporal unions

Notice that this type of union does not put the Lord at the center of the relationship and will not last over time. The Lord says in D&C 132:15:

if a man marry him a wife in the world, and he marry her not by me nor by my word, and he covenant with her so long as he is in the world and she with him, their covenant and marriage are not of force when they are dead, and when they are out of the world; therefore, they are not bound by any law when they are out of the world.

A close reading of D&C 132 makes it clear, in language that is legalistic in nature, that the Lord only recognizes marriages that are sealed through priesthood power. Marriage has a very specific definition, and this cannot be changed by the world. The good news is, however, that true marriages based on love and mutual respect can be sealed after people have died for time and all eternity in the temple. The Lord’s plan provides a way of solemnizing these marriages after people have died.

Before we came to the Earth we saw Satan’s plan for the counterfeit that it was. Now it behooves us to continue to watch for counterfeit plans and reject them. We can recognize the true plans if we follow modern-day prophets and the scriptures.

This entry was posted in General by Geoff B.. Bookmark the permalink.

About Geoff B.

Geoff B has had three main careers. Some of them have overlapped. After attending Stanford University (class of 1985), he worked in journalism for several years until about 1992, when he took up his second career in telecommunications sales. In 1995, he took up his favorite and third career as father. Soon thereafter, Heavenly Father hit him over the head with a two-by-four (wielded by the Holy Ghost) and he woke up from a long sleep. Since then, he's been learning a lot about the Gospel. He still has a lot to learn. Geoff's held several Church callings: young men's president, high priest group leader, member of the bishopric, stake director of public affairs, media specialist for church public affairs, high councilman. He tries his best in his callings but usually falls short. Geoff has five children and lives in Colorado.

16 thoughts on “True and counterfeit plans through the eternities

  1. Good job on the graphics, and great points. I especially like the one on marriage focused on the Lord. It was explained to me that way too, that in marriage, you face the Lord together, you don’t face each other.

  2. Except that it is God the Father’s plan, not Christ’s. That’s why he, Christ, said: “Thy will be done” – instead of suggesting a plan himself.

    Also I think part of the “War in Heaven” was about whether Christ could actually accomplish the work. We had to be willing to exercise Faith in Christ in order to choose to follow the Father’s Plan. Because if we came down here and Christ wasn’t able to accomplish the Atonement than we would all be left out of the Father’s presence for all eternity – as no unclean thing can enter into the presence of the Father.

    Other than those “nit-picky” points I think the post is a very good exposition of many of the basic differences between a Gospel centered view of life and some of the “World’s” alternative views. Lots of work here obviously, thank you for putting forth the effort.

  3. I don’t believe that Satan wanted to force humanity to be good. I think he wanted everyone to choose whatever we wanted to do without consequences, thereby destroying our agency. Satan wanted to save us IN our sins, not save us FROM our sins, which was our Heavenly Father’s plan. Without differing results from our choices, there is no agency, no right or wrong, no good or evil–the same moral relativism we see being taught by the world today. The real battle is in having both faith in Jesus Christ to overcome all and accepting personal responsibility for our choices or to follow the natural man and expect to not have bad consequences.

  4. okcom and LDSP, I kind of agree. Yes, Satan may have promised that people could be saved in their sins and no soul would be lost. My point is more about the end-game. If you allow people to “follow the natural man” and basically do whatever they want without consequences you very quickly create chaos. If Satan were the hero of the plan, it is natural that he would be the strong man or tyrant who would step in to create order. This would eventually mean forcing people to “be good” (whatever that might mean to Satan). I personally believe there were a lot of spirits who saw through his plan to Satan’s end game.

  5. I definitely agree with okcmom. Satan’s plan is– do whatever you want, and you’ll be saved– and this plan is the same one he uses today. It was a popular plan in the pre-existence and it is popular today with many people. Satan’s plan was never about forcing people to do good. People have free will in Satan’s plan, because they are free to do whatever they want, but there are no eternal consequences. With God’s plan we also have free choice, but we must follow the path He set if we want to gain eternal life. There is no growth in Satan’s plan. Satan’s plan is– going to college and being guaranteed a diploma, with no effort required. God’s plan requires effort to earn a diploma–and thus gain knowledge and progression–to eventually return to His presence.

  6. Custer, that is fine, but I will repeat that this is not Satan’s end game. It seems to me he is using the “do whatever you want and you will be saved” card for a longer plan, which is to take control for himself. And that will eventually involve forcing people do be good (according to his definition of good) once he has control. When we concentrate on the short term we miss the bigger picture and the incredible evil in Satan’s plan. This also explains why he continues to act the way he does even though he has to know he will eventually lose.

  7. I’d like to expand on this theme a bit. I think worldly tyrants give us a model for what Satan really wants. So, if Satan allows people to be saved in their sins, what is in it for him? He gets a lot of people doing whatever they want and being “saved.” How does that benefit Satan? We know and Satan knows that such a system will create chaos, first of all, and chaos leaves the potential for another leader (not Satan) to take over eventually. Obviously, this cannot be what he wants. No, Satan’s plan must guarantee power for him and nobody else. So, he attracts his followers with the old canard that the Lord’s way is too strict and intolerant of diversity, etc, etc. He must fool his followers into believing that he truly cares about them (which he does not). So, step one is making the claim that everybody can and should be saved. Once he has a group of followers buying into this, there will inevitably be a lot of disorder. Satan will blame the disorder on the spirits who do not follow him to whip up his followers against a common enemy. Satan maintains his leadership position as the only one who can unify his spirits against the enemy. Once he has consolidated power completely, he can set up his totalitarian universe where free agency disappears and where everybody eventually is forced to follow the model that Satan creates. This will involve people behaving in a certain way (Satan’s way) for the “common good.”

    Satan’s plan cannot simply be “do whatever you want and you’ll be saved” because this is not a long-term plan that puts Satan at the center.

    (I accept that the model is likely much more complex than this with many things we cannot understand right now. I am using earthly words and concepts to describe something that is not earthly. But I maintain that we make a mistake if we do not see the end point of what Satan wants).

  8. I think Geoff is correct. For a mortal parallel, consider addiction.

    On the surface, indulging in a substance or behavior – alcohol, drugs, cigarettes, gambling, pornography – is “freedom” from the rules and commandments that proscribe the behavior. But addicts find it difficult or even impossible to escape. As the Book of Mormon describes, the devil “cheateth their souls, and leadeth them away carefully down to hell.” He’s still working his plan on Father’s children, and we can watch its implementation on individuals in real-time.

Comments are closed.